HIDE

Other Publications

Insights

Publications

How Not to Borrow a Treaty: Smith v. Commr.

How Not to Borrow a Treaty: Smith v. Commr.

For individual entrepreneurs operating across the globe, generating profits in corporations based in tax favored jurisdictions is a key ingredient in making and keeping a substantial share of profits. However, when the entrepreneur is a U.S. citizen, bringing those profits home requires careful planning in order to take advantage of the qualified dividend rules. Having a structure that is on the right side of the rules reduces the income tax rate on dividends to 20%. Having a structure on the wrong side, leaves the top rate at 37%. Too many entrepreneurs wait until the last minute to plan and even then have difficulty in following a plan based on tax law and economic substance. Galia Antebi and Stanley C. Ruchelman discuss a case in which one taxpayer was addicted to cutting corners or did not appreciate the risk when deviating from a plan. Whatever the reason, the plan crafted by his tax advisers never made it to the implementation stage. On paper, the plan worked. In substance, nothing was done. Big tax resulted.

Read More